2016 U.S. Trust Study of High Net Worth Philanthropy Reveals Positive Giving and Volunteering Forecasts for the Coming Years
New Study Offers Insight Into the Motivations, Expectations and Behaviors of Various Demographic Segments of Wealthy Donors
Most wealthy individuals believe charitable giving (45 percent) and volunteering (31 percent) have the greatest potential for positive impact on society –far more so than voting for (13 percent) or contributing to (1 percent) a political candidate who shares their ideals on topics important to them – according to the 2016 U.S. Trust® Study of High Net Worth Philanthropy. Through an ongoing partnership with the Indiana University Lilly Family School of Philanthropy, the sixth in this series of biennial studies reveals a strong commitment to charitable causes among high net worth (HNW) households, and giving and volunteering levels poised to increase in future years:
- Last year, the vast majority (91 percent) of HNW households donated to charity. This high rate of giving among the wealthy compares with 59 percent of the U.S. general population who donate to charity.1
- Fifty percent of wealthy individuals volunteered their time and talents last year to charitable organizations they care about – twice the rate of the general population (25 percent).2
- The study offers an optimistic view of future giving levels, with 83 percent of wealthy individuals planning to give as much (55 percent) or more (28 percent) in the next three years (through 2018) than they have in the past. Women, African Americans, and younger individuals (age 50 and under) are even more likely to increase their giving in the next three years.
- Future levels of volunteerism are also promising. Among wealthy individuals who currently volunteer, 90 percent say they plan to do so as much (60 percent) or more (30 percent) over the next three years. Even among those who did not volunteer last year, 39 percent plan to do so during the coming years.
“Wealthy donors continue to be incredibly generous with their time and money in support of social change in their communities and in the world,” said Claire Costello, national philanthropic practice executive for U.S. Trust. “And while their charitable activity is driven to a large extent by their personal values and convictions, donors are also listening closely to the needs of nonprofits as they make their giving and volunteering decisions.”
This research series is the most comprehensive and longest-running of its kind, and an important barometer for wealthy donors’ charitable engagement and perspectives. Key findings from this latest research offer valuable insights that help inform the strategies of nonprofit professionals, wealthy donors and charitable advisors alike. The study is based on a nationally representative random sample of wealthy individuals, including, for the first time, deeper analysis based on age, gender, sexual orientation and race. This expanded methodology enables further exploration of the philanthropic trends, strategies, and behaviors among the HNW population.
And the recipients are…
On average, wealthy donors gave to eight different nonprofit organizations last year. However, this number varied based on a donor’s age – for instance, donors over the age of 70 gave to an average of 11 organizations and baby boomers gave to seven, whereas younger donors (age 50 and under) gave to five.
Sixty-three percent of wealthy donors gave to basic needs organizations last year – making it the charitable subsector supported by the largest percentage of HNW households. Additional causes supported by the greatest percentages of wealthy donors included religion (50 percent), education (45 percent), the environment (42 percent) and health (40 percent). With respect to giving to education, 31 percent of respondents gave to higher education and 33 percent gave to K–12 education.
Volunteers give more
Among the wealthy, volunteering with a nonprofit organization has a strong correlation with giving to that organization. A large majority of HNW individuals (84 percent) give financially to at least some of the organizations with which they volunteer, while 49 percent give to most, if not all, of the organizations where they volunteer.
The study found that volunteerism also has an influence on giving levels. Wealthy individuals who volunteered in 2015 gave 56 percent more on average than those who did not volunteer.3
While many wealthy individuals experience a high degree of personal fulfillment from their charitable giving (42 percent), even more experience it through their volunteerism (63 percent). Women reported deriving greater levels of fulfillment from volunteering than men, as did younger individuals when compared to those over the age of 50.
Motivations, expectations and challenges
A variety of motivations drive HNW philanthropy. In 2015, wealthy households cited the following among the primary reasons they give: believing in the mission of the organization (54 percent); believing that their gift can make a difference (44 percent); experiencing personal satisfaction, enjoyment or fulfillment (39 percent); supporting the same causes annually (36 percent); giving back to the community (27 percent); and adhering to religious beliefs (23 percent). Just 18 percent of wealthy donors said they gave largely because of tax benefits in 2015.
Wealthy donors have strong feelings about how the nonprofits they support should use their contributions and conduct themselves. After making a charitable gift, 89 percent of wealthy donors said it is important that the organization spend only a reasonable amount of their donation on general administrative and fundraising expenses. Wealthy donors also indicated that it is important that the organization demonstrate sound business and operational practices (89 percent), acknowledge donations by providing a receipt for tax purposes (88 percent), not distribute their names to others (84 percent), and honor their requests for anonymity (83 percent) and for how their gift is to be used (83 percent).
Nearly one out of five wealthy individuals stopped giving to at least one nonprofit organization last year. When individuals stopped giving to a particular charity they previously supported, among the reasons cited were because they received too frequent solicitation from the organization (41 percent), circumstances in their household changed (40 percent), the organization was not effective or did not sufficiently communicate its effectiveness (18 percent), or the organization asked for an amount the donor felt was inappropriate (14 percent).
Wealthy individuals reported their greatest challenge when it comes to charitable giving is identifying what causes they care about and deciding where to donate (67 percent). Other charitable giving challenges include understanding how much they can afford to give (50 percent), allocating time to volunteer with the organizations they care about (45 percent), and monitoring giving to ensure it has its intended impact (37 percent).
This study also found that, among the 33 percent of wealthy donors who participate in impact investing, 61 percent approach it as something they do in addition to their existing charitable giving, whereas 34 percent do so in place of at least some of their charitable giving. And just 5 percent of wealthy donors participate in impact investing in place of all of their charitable giving.
Higher levels of charitable giving knowledge improve the giving experience
The study found notable relationships between wealthy individuals’ level of knowledge about giving and their giving behaviors and characteristics. When comparing individuals by levels of charitable giving knowledge (i.e., expert, knowledgeable, novice), higher levels of knowledge directly correlate with whether individuals monitor the impact of their giving, believe their giving is having its intended impact, consult with advisors, and utilize giving vehicles (e.g., private foundation, donor-advised fund), as well as with greater personal fulfillment from giving and higher average giving amounts.
Overall, 44 percent of wealthy donors believe their giving is having the impact they intended, while 54 percent are not sure whether their gifts are achieving the impact they desire. This may be partly due to the fact that 78 percent of wealthy donors do not monitor or evaluate the impact of their charitable giving.
Nearly all wealthy individuals (94 percent) would like to be more knowledgeable about at least one aspect of charitable giving, with the highest percentages of these individuals interested in learning how to identify the right volunteer opportunities (42 percent), becoming more familiar with nonprofits and how they serve their constituents’ needs (29 percent), and how to engage the next generation in philanthropic giving (20 percent).
“Nonprofits that understand the priorities and expectations of their wealthy donors, engage them in meaningful and fulfilling ways, and communicate the organization’s impact can effectively partner with donors to achieve their mutual goals for a better world,” said Una Osili, Ph.D., professor of economics and philanthropic studies and director of research for the Indiana University Lilly Family School of Philanthropy.
Making giving a family affair
Among the 79 percent of HNW households surveyed who indicated having children, grandchildren or other younger relatives, just 21 percent have family traditions around giving, such as volunteering as a family or giving together to charity during the holidays. African Americans, Asian Americans, Hispanics and women were significantly more likely to indicate that their household has family traditions around giving. Younger individuals were twice as likely to have family traditions around giving as those over the age of 50.
Similarly, far more individuals reported not involving their younger relatives in their giving (72 percent) than those who do (28 percent). Once again, African Americans, Hispanics, women and younger individuals were significantly more likely to indicate that they have involved younger relatives in their giving. Among wealthy individuals who involve younger relatives in their giving, the majority found the experience personally rewarding (77 percent).
When asked how they would like to ultimately distribute their wealth, HNW individuals reported that they intend to leave the majority to their children and grandchildren (75 percent), with other heirs receiving the second-highest percentage (14 percent). Respondents intend to leave 12 percent of their wealth to charities (8 percent to secular charities, and 4 percent to religious charities).
Electing to give, and giving to elect
Twenty-four percent of wealthy individuals contributed to a political candidate, campaign or committee last year or plan to do so during the 2016 election season. Among this group, donors over the age of 70 (40 percent) and LGBT individuals (38 percent) were more likely to make such political contributions.
Among those who contributed to a political candidate or campaign, wealthy individuals reported doing so because they:
- View it as an opportunity to exercise their voice (56 percent).
- Hope to influence the outcome of elections (49 percent).
- Believe their contribution can make a difference (46 percent).
The main reasons why 76 percent of wealthy individuals have not and do not plan to make political contributions during this election season include:
- Feeling such contributions would have little to no impact when compared to corporate contributions (47 percent) and contributions from political action committees (PACs) (26 percent).
- Believing such contributions won’t make a difference (31 percent).
- Not having a particular candidate they would endorse (26 percent).
Results of this study are based on a survey of 1,435 U.S. households with a net worth of $1 million or more (excluding the value of their primary home) and/or an annual household income of $200,000 or more. To view a detailed summary of key findings and to access the full report, visit www.ustrust.com/philanthropy.
1 2013 Philanthropy Panel Study on giving in 2012, the latest year data is available on average giving by American households
2 2013 U.S. Volunteering and Civic Engagement Study
3 Average giving amounts are calculated excluding ultra high net worth households (those with a wealth level greater than $20 million) because our data is only able to provide an aggregate value for giving by these households, not individual giving values. We cannot use an aggregate value when looking at individual characteristics.
The Indiana University Lilly Family School of Philanthropy
The Indiana University Lilly Family School of Philanthropy is dedicated to improving philanthropy to improve the world by training and empowering students and professionals to be innovators and leaders who create positive and lasting change. The school offers a comprehensive approach to philanthropy through its academic, research and international programs and through The Fund Raising School, Lake Institute on Faith & Giving, and the Women’s Philanthropy Institute. For more information, visit www.philanthropy.iupui.edu.
U.S. Trust’s Philanthropic Solutions Group
U.S. Trust’s Philanthropic Solutions Group serves the needs of nonprofit institutions, philanthropic individuals and families across the investment businesses with Bank of America. Philanthropic Solutions distributes more than $300 million in grants to charitable organizations annually on behalf of clients where U.S. Trust serves as trustee, co-trustee or grant-making agent. The investment businesses within Bank of America, including U.S. Trust, Merrill Lynch Wealth Management and the Merrill Lynch Private Banking and Investment Group are among the nation's leading providers of investment and philanthropic services to individuals, families, foundations, endowments and other nonprofit organizations.
Bank of America
Bank of America is one of the world's leading financial institutions, serving individual consumers, small and middle-market businesses and large corporations with a full range of banking, investing, asset management and other financial and risk management products and services. The company provides unmatched convenience in the United States, serving approximately 47 million consumer and small business relationships with approximately 4,600 retail financial centers, approximately 16,000 ATMs, and award-winning online banking with approximately 34 million active accounts and more than 21 million mobile active users. Bank of America is a global leader in wealth management, corporate and investment banking and trading across a broad range of asset classes, serving corporations, governments, institutions and individuals around the world. Bank of America offers industry-leading support to approximately 3 million small business owners through a suite of innovative, easy-to-use online products and services. The company serves clients through operations in all 50 states, the District of Columbia, the U.S. Virgin Islands, Puerto Rico and more than 35 countries. Bank of America Corporation stock (NYSE: BAC) is listed on the New York Stock Exchange.
Institutional Investments & Philanthropic Solutions (“Philanthropic Solutions”) is part of U.S. Trust, Bank of America Corporation (“U.S. Trust”). U.S. Trust operates through Bank of America, N.A. and other subsidiaries of Bank of America Corporation (“BofA Corp.”). Bank of America, N.A., Member FDIC. Banking and fiduciary activities are performed by wholly owned banking affiliates of BofA Corp., including Bank of America, N.A.
|Are Not FDIC Insured||Are Not Bank Guaranteed||May Lose Value|